
Bill 216 – Are More Changes to Ontario’s Construction Act on the Way?
March 5, 2025
Buyers of Pre-Build Condos Beware of Timelines to Respond to Material Changes
May 6, 2025
About the Series:
Liens 101 is a series of articles focusing exclusively on Ontario’s construction liens. This series will provide an overview of some of the most common issues and questions clients face when dealing with a lien, addressing the step-by-step process applicable to all construction liens in Ontario.
In this article, we will be covering how defects in workmanship by the builder impact the lien amount, and the use of the Scott Schedule in construction lien claims.
Defects, Incomplete Work and Extras
Defects and incomplete work are common in construction projects. Even the best, most qualified builders and subcontractors sometimes make mistakes. At other times, the true conditions of a property are not known until the work is underway and the initial plans may no longer be possible. Likewise, delays and cost overruns can make original ideas financially impossible for owners to go through with and it might be necessary to change the original design idea as well. At other times, owners
Whatever the reason, it is not surprising for lawyers to hear that a project looks different in the end from what was originally designed. This is especially likely to happen when owners undertake major renovations or complete overhauls of their property – the more work that needs to be done, the more labourers and subcontractors that have to be hired, and the more people that are involved, the greater the likelihood that issues will arise.
The difficulty in construction lien claims comes about when owners are trying to sort through exactly what went wrong during construction. It is not enough to claim a builder or subcontractor failed to build what you requested in a general sense; you have to specify exactly where the failures lie. This is where Scott Schedules come into play.
Scott Schedules
Scott Schedules are charts that are used in construction lien claims to individually identify all deficiencies, incomplete work, and any extra work that did not form part of the original contract between the owner and builder but that was agreed to by the parties during the life of the project. The Scott Schedule will set out a detailed description of each item that is at issue and the cost associated with the item, with both the lien claimant and the defendant having an opportunity to address each line item. There will usually also be a final section for the Judge to put in their decision for the item.
The purpose of a Scott Schedule is to set out all the construction issues in an easy-to-read format – all parties in a litigation work on the same document, input their comments and cost amounts in the same document and see the Judge’s final decision for that line item.
Scott Schedules are ordered by the Court. They are not necessary in every case, especially if there is a more simple and straight-forward lien claim that does not require the amount of details needed for a Scott Schedule, but they are used in most lien actions. In addition, unlike other court forms, the Scott Schedule is not a formal document that is available on the official court forms website; rather, parties prepare their own Scott Schedule based on established standards of practice within the construction lien industry.
Benefits of Scott Schedules
- Clarifies the Issues: Identifies what the specific issues are that came up during construction.
- Neutral Format: Written in a fact-specific manner which aids in dispute resolution.
- Facilitates Resolutions: Scott Schedules can often lead to the resolution of individual line items, and sometimes even the dispute as a whole.
- Reduces Court Costs and Time: By clarifying and narrowing down the issues, this process can save a lot of court time and overall costs.
Conclusion
As you can see, Scott Schedules are not complicated documents and there is next-to-no “legalese” in them. Rather, they provide an organized way for parties to address the construction issues that come up during a project.
Next Article
Join us for our next article where we will examine the holdback regime under the Construction Act.



