
35 minutes late is still late: Ontario Court of Appeal affirms a strict closing deadline in a real estate transaction gone awry.
July 9, 2024
Goodbye NOSIs – Ontario Puts an End to Predatory Security Instruments
October 23, 2024Introduction
In 2018, Ontario’s Construction Act, RSO 1990, c C.30 (the “Act”) underwent a major overhaul following years and years of legislative consultancy and debate. One of the notable changes included the addition of the Prompt Payment regime and Adjudication process, as outlined in Parts I.1 and II.1 of the Act, respectively, which allows contracting parties to expeditiously resolve disputes revolving around non-payment of invoices.
As an out-of-court proceeding, adjudications are sometimes considered “rough justice,” as there are typically less stringent procedural rules and rights in order to encourage speedy resolutions. Nevertheless, this focus on efficiency does not override well-established legal principles concerning procedural fairness, namely the fundamental right to be heard during a legal proceeding.
Adjudicators’ decisions will typically receive deference from the courts on appeal, and successfully appealing an adjudicator’s decision will be an uphill battle. However, courts won’t blindly uphold a decision and are willing to take the extraordinary measure of setting aside a ruling when it is necessary to do so.
With the release of Ledore Investments v. Dixin Construction, 2024 ONSC 598, earlier this year, Ontario now has its first officially reported decision where a court determined it was necessary to overturn an adjudicator’s ruling under the new Prompt Payment and Adjudication regimes of the Act.
Background
Ledore Investments (“Ledore”), operating under the business name “Ross Steel Fabricators & Contractors,” was a subcontractor to Dixin Construction (“Dixon”), the general contractor on a construction project at Lambton College in Toronto. Ledore provided its services and issued three invoices to Dixin for its work, totalling $349,263.57.
Dixin never raised concerns about the amount of the invoices, and they never served a Notice of Non-Payment on Ledore within the time limits prescribed by the Act. Dixin did, however, receive full payment from the owner, part of which should have gone towards Ledore for its services, so there was no issue that Dixin lacked the funds to pay Ledore.
Ledore filed a notice to have the matter determined through adjudication. In the result, the adjudicator declined to order Dixin to pay Ledore, holding that because Dixin had not delivered a “proper invoice” to the owner, the Act’s prompt payment provisions were never triggered and therefore did not apply.
Neither Ledore nor Dixin had raised this point as an issue for adjudication, but the adjudicator found this issue to be determinative and relied on it without any input from the parties. Interestingly, the adjudicator noted his concern with his own outcome, stating at paragraph 45 of his decision:
“I feel it necessary to note that I am concerned with the outcome in this matter, as it appears [Dixin] is able to (unintentionally, it would seem) take advantage of its own failure to comply with the Act.”
Ledore appealed the adjudicator’s decision to the Divisional Court.
The Appeal
The Divisional Court allowed Ledore’s appeal, setting aside the adjudicator’s decision.
In its decision, the Divisional Court noted that while Ledore was not entitled to the full range of procedural protections that would apply to a court hearing, for example, the right to be heard on determinative issues is a core principle of our justice system. The procedural entitlements provided in adjudication were not so low as to eliminate the fundamental right to be heard.
In other words, adjudication provides for a fast and informal process for resolving disputes, but that does not mean that it is devoid of procedural protection or that it operates without the application of well-established legal principles.
The Divisional Court further noted that the adjudicator could have requested written submissions on the invoicing issue pursuant to section 13.12(1) of the Act, which expressly authorizes an adjudicator to issue directions respecting the conduct of the adjudication. As such, the adjudicator had the authority to seek further submissions on the new issue he identified and could have extended the adjudication process to accommodate the request. While this would go against the efficiency goals of adjudication, those goals do not matter more than the right to be heard.
As a result, the Divisional Court remitted the matter back to adjudication so that the parties could make submissions on the invoicing issue.
Takeaways
The new adjudication regime under the Act offers contracting parties a speedy process for resolving disputes over payment of invoices, one of the most common disputes that arises in construction matters. Though, as Ledore reminds us, efficiency cannot come at the cost of long-held legal principles and rights. The right to be heard is one of the key tenets of procedural fairness, affording parties the “reasonable opportunity to present their points of view, respond to facts presented by others, and have their arguments considered by the decision-maker”. Even if the final result reached by the decision maker is defensible from a substantive point of view, like it arguably was in Ledore, the failure to provide parties with an opportunity to address the core issue can result in that decision being set aside.



